{
  "study": "STOAD V3 versus explicitly idealised metal D-handle",
  "date": "2026-10-23",
  "status": "Illustrative elastic geometry study; no qualified working load, fatigue life or failure prediction",
  "material_reference": "https://www.outokumpu.com/en/products/product-ranges/supra",
  "solver_reference": "https://www.dhondt.de/",
  "solver": "CalculiX 2.23",
  "mesh": "Gmsh 4.15.0; V21 straight-sided C3D10 with quadratic displacement, faceted geometry; idealised D-handle retains curved C3D10. Positive mapping checked at integration points, vertices, edge midpoints, face centres and centroid",
  "basis_force_N": 100,
  "models": [
    {
      "model": "v3",
      "source_sha256": "287834599673436956b1dc1e49db2ce452c3716221c29b72eb2ad5df70a93ca7",
      "E_MPa": 200000.0,
      "nu": 0.3,
      "density_kg_m3": 8000,
      "cad_volume_mm3": 461608.1249031781,
      "mesh_volume_mm3": 455685.86910019815,
      "min_integration_Jacobian": 8.745127389478985e-05,
      "checks": [
        {
          "case": "up",
          "force_balance_N": 4.8356857350822e-06,
          "moment_balance_Nmm": 0.0001010575015174755,
          "free_node_residual_N": 6.019366470633145e-07,
          "loaded_area_mm2": 404.6908028921617
        },
        {
          "case": "down",
          "force_balance_N": 3.975382218021698e-06,
          "moment_balance_Nmm": 0.00029540253243231883,
          "free_node_residual_N": 5.652763271629143e-07,
          "loaded_area_mm2": 378.2427110992723
        },
        {
          "case": "gravity",
          "force_balance_N": 2.2219060508706194e-06,
          "moment_balance_Nmm": 5.5416234639390226e-05,
          "free_node_residual_N": 4.011359696406301e-08,
          "loaded_area_mm2": 0.0
        }
      ],
      "fixture": "All translations fixed on exterior grip radius 17 mm, |x| < 50 mm; no pad restraint",
      "bore_load": "100 N resultant traction distributed with quadratic triangle quadrature over upper/lower bore sector",
      "gravity": "Independent consistent body nodal load; fixed -Z direction; linear superposition does not scale gravity with cable force",
      "surface": "Element-mean 4 integration-point stress tensor painted onto four subdivisions of each boundary tri6; unsmoothed element colours; separate full integration point maxima",
      "not_modelled": [
        "plasticity",
        "fracture",
        "fatigue",
        "impact",
        "manufacturing defects",
        "anisotropy",
        "pad/contact mechanics",
        "weld/joint failure"
      ],
      "geometry_mapping": "Straight-sided C3D10, quadratic displacement with faceted geometry. Curved high-order mapping rejected for negative Jacobians.",
      "geometry_volume_tolerance_pct": 2,
      "convergence": "Single accepted display mesh; nominal V21 CAD mass and mesh-integrated gravity differ by the reported volume error. No mesh-converged maximum claimed",
      "metrics": {
        "up": {
          "0": {
            "25": {
              "vm": 1.05082,
              "u": 0.0013985
            },
            "50": {
              "vm": 2.10165,
              "u": 0.002797
            },
            "75": {
              "vm": 3.15247,
              "u": 0.0041955
            },
            "100": {
              "vm": 4.2033,
              "u": 0.0055939
            },
            "125": {
              "vm": 5.25412,
              "u": 0.0069924
            },
            "150": {
              "vm": 6.30495,
              "u": 0.0083909
            }
          },
          "1": {
            "25": {
              "vm": 0.98016,
              "u": 0.0008982
            },
            "50": {
              "vm": 2.03098,
              "u": 0.0013675
            },
            "75": {
              "vm": 3.08181,
              "u": 0.0027004
            },
            "100": {
              "vm": 4.13263,
              "u": 0.0040427
            },
            "125": {
              "vm": 5.18346,
              "u": 0.0053872
            },
            "150": {
              "vm": 6.23428,
              "u": 0.0067327
            }
          }
        },
        "down": {
          "0": {
            "25": {
              "vm": 0.94534,
              "u": 0.0013985
            },
            "50": {
              "vm": 1.89068,
              "u": 0.0027969
            },
            "75": {
              "vm": 2.83603,
              "u": 0.0041954
            },
            "100": {
              "vm": 3.78137,
              "u": 0.0055939
            },
            "125": {
              "vm": 4.72671,
              "u": 0.0069923
            },
            "150": {
              "vm": 5.67205,
              "u": 0.0083908
            }
          },
          "1": {
            "25": {
              "vm": 1.32807,
              "u": 0.0035154
            },
            "50": {
              "vm": 1.96463,
              "u": 0.004913
            },
            "75": {
              "vm": 2.90667,
              "u": 0.0063106
            },
            "100": {
              "vm": 3.85201,
              "u": 0.0077083
            },
            "125": {
              "vm": 4.79736,
              "u": 0.009106
            },
            "150": {
              "vm": 5.7427,
              "u": 0.0105037
            }
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "basic",
      "source_sha256": "1cfdaa7855e7d7ec08f357db4bbdfa7489757a39c2edbb5e44f1509c93381f01",
      "E_MPa": 200000.0,
      "nu": 0.3,
      "density_kg_m3": 8000,
      "cad_volume_mm3": 92018.71922895216,
      "mesh_volume_mm3": 92002.81806459588,
      "min_integration_Jacobian": 2.845093585597763,
      "checks": [
        {
          "case": "up",
          "force_balance_N": 3.0702048138259823e-06,
          "moment_balance_Nmm": 5.5944193555939836e-05,
          "free_node_residual_N": 1.4990349254257778e-06,
          "loaded_area_mm2": 165.42955544869665
        },
        {
          "case": "down",
          "force_balance_N": 3.698003906695279e-06,
          "moment_balance_Nmm": 9.39603237706774e-05,
          "free_node_residual_N": 1.723441983331826e-06,
          "loaded_area_mm2": 162.19450287031256
        },
        {
          "case": "gravity",
          "force_balance_N": 1.7342072960637966e-07,
          "moment_balance_Nmm": 4.7767056114763566e-06,
          "free_node_residual_N": 1.4422991120767211e-08,
          "loaded_area_mm2": 0.0
        }
      ],
      "fixture": "All translations fixed on exterior grip radius 17 mm, |x| < 50 mm; no pad restraint",
      "bore_load": "100 N resultant traction distributed with quadratic triangle quadrature over upper/lower bore sector",
      "gravity": "Independent consistent body nodal load; fixed -Z direction; linear superposition does not scale gravity with cable force",
      "surface": "Element-mean 4 integration-point stress tensor painted onto four subdivisions of each boundary tri6; unsmoothed element colours; separate full integration point maxima",
      "not_modelled": [
        "plasticity",
        "fracture",
        "fatigue",
        "impact",
        "manufacturing defects",
        "anisotropy",
        "pad/contact mechanics",
        "weld/joint failure"
      ],
      "convergence": "Single mesh illustrative geometry comparison; no mesh-converged maximum claimed",
      "metrics": {
        "up": {
          "0": {
            "25": {
              "vm": 2.53485,
              "u": 0.0011056
            },
            "50": {
              "vm": 5.06969,
              "u": 0.0022111
            },
            "75": {
              "vm": 7.60454,
              "u": 0.0033167
            },
            "100": {
              "vm": 10.13939,
              "u": 0.0044223
            },
            "125": {
              "vm": 12.67424,
              "u": 0.0055278
            },
            "150": {
              "vm": 15.20908,
              "u": 0.0066334
            }
          },
          "1": {
            "25": {
              "vm": 2.45239,
              "u": 0.0010522
            },
            "50": {
              "vm": 4.98723,
              "u": 0.0021578
            },
            "75": {
              "vm": 7.52208,
              "u": 0.0032633
            },
            "100": {
              "vm": 10.05692,
              "u": 0.0043689
            },
            "125": {
              "vm": 12.59177,
              "u": 0.0054745
            },
            "150": {
              "vm": 15.12662,
              "u": 0.00658
            }
          }
        },
        "down": {
          "0": {
            "25": {
              "vm": 2.36628,
              "u": 0.0011751
            },
            "50": {
              "vm": 4.73256,
              "u": 0.0023502
            },
            "75": {
              "vm": 7.09883,
              "u": 0.0035253
            },
            "100": {
              "vm": 9.46511,
              "u": 0.0047004
            },
            "125": {
              "vm": 11.83139,
              "u": 0.0058755
            },
            "150": {
              "vm": 14.19767,
              "u": 0.0070506
            }
          },
          "1": {
            "25": {
              "vm": 2.44881,
              "u": 0.0012285
            },
            "50": {
              "vm": 4.81509,
              "u": 0.0024036
            },
            "75": {
              "vm": 7.18137,
              "u": 0.0035787
            },
            "100": {
              "vm": 9.54764,
              "u": 0.0047538
            },
            "125": {
              "vm": 11.91392,
              "u": 0.0059289
            },
            "150": {
              "vm": 14.2802,
              "u": 0.007104
            }
          }
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "idealised_D": {
    "valid": true,
    "solids": 1,
    "volume_mm3": 92018.71922895216,
    "bounds_mm": [
      164.5236144444439,
      34.0,
      166.0
    ],
    "grip_OD_mm": 34,
    "grip_inner_OD_mm": 28,
    "grip_internal_void_length_mm": 120,
    "grip_total_length_mm": 140,
    "grip_clear_span_mm": 128,
    "frame_rod_diameter_mm": 12,
    "eye_OD_ID_mm": [
      32,
      16
    ],
    "eye_thickness_mm": 10,
    "eye_center_xyz_mm": [
      0,
      0,
      133
    ],
    "source": "New explicitly idealised D-handle geometry, not a scanned or measured commercial product",
    "joint_assumption": "Perfectly fused body; no weld, bearing, sliding or assembly failure model"
  },
  "public_data_sha256": "f59b3dac62e3153f5428a63e4b40602552134018db268d13842adfd089ab00ee",
  "engineering_revision": "V21_WIDE_CLEARANCE_STUDY",
  "geometry_disclosure": "V21 mesh volume differs from exact CAD by 1.283%; nominal displayed V21 mass is from CAD, self-weight is integrated on the mesh. Single-mesh illustrative comparison, not converged peak-stress or physical load qualification."
}
